top of page

Shotgun Metagenomic Testing for Helicobacter pylori

2 days ago
4 min read

Updated: 21 hours ago


My most recent blog post discussed the detection of Helicobacter pylori (H. pylori) infection through upper endoscopy (EGD) and gastric biopsy histopathology. Today, I would like to discuss another testing method that may or may not be helpful in identifying this infection.


Some time ago, I saw a new patient whom I wanted to evaluate for H. pylori. We reviewed the available testing options, but the patient expressed interest in a particular method they had learned about from a YouTuber whom I believe was a functional medicine dietitian. The test utilized a technology called shotgun metagenomic sequencing, which, at the time, was unfamiliar to me.


I watched the dietitian's YouTube video, in which she compared three different methods of testing for H. pylori. She expressed the opinion that PCR testing tends to "overdiagnose" the infection and is therefore not an accurate method of detection. To support her position, she described a patient who had undergone both shotgun metagenomic sequencing and PCR testing at approximately the same time. The shotgun metagenomic test was negative for H. pylori, while the PCR test was positive. She interpreted these conflicting results as evidence that PCR testing had produced a false-positive result.


This AI generated image shows the process of Shotgun Metagenomics testing.
This AI generated image shows the process of Shotgun Metagenomics testing.

What Is Shotgun Metagenomic Sequencing?


My initial research revealed that shotgun metagenomic sequencing shares some

similarities with PCR testing because both methods analyze genetic material. However, there is a significant difference in how they identify microorganisms. PCR testing looks for specific, predetermined DNA sequences associated with a particular organism. Shotgun metagenomic sequencing, on the other hand, takes a much broader approach. It sequences numerous DNA fragments from a specimen and then uses computer-based analysis to compare those fragments against genetic databases containing the known DNA sequences of bacteria, viruses, and other microorganisms.


In a sense, shotgun metagenomic sequencing works backward compared with targeted PCR. Rather than starting with a specific organism and looking for its DNA, the laboratory starts with the DNA recovered from the specimen and attempts to determine which organisms it belongs to. This distinction is particularly important when considering whether the test is appropriate for identifying a specific infection such as H. pylori.


It may also provide information about the genetic capacity of these microorganisms, including genes associated with antibiotic resistance or specific metabolic pathways. But there is an important distinction here. Identifying genes involved in a metabolic pathway does not necessarily mean that pathway is active. Shotgun metagenomics identifies genetic potential.


I think this distinction is important because microbiome testing is sometimes marketed in a way that makes the results appear more definitive than the science currently supports.



Can Shotgun Metagenomic Testing Detect H. pylori?


Maybe. Shotgun metagenomic testing can detect H. pylori DNA if sufficient genetic material is present in the specimen and the laboratory's sequencing and analysis methods can identify it. However, that does not mean it is necessarily the best method for diagnosing this infection.


One of the biggest challenges is where H. pylori lives. Unlike many intestinal bacteria, H. pylori primarily colonizes the stomach, particularly the mucus layer overlying the gastric lining. When a stool specimen is collected, the laboratory is primarily examining microorganisms and genetic material that have traveled through the intestinal tract. Only a relatively small amount of H. pylori genetic material may be present in stool, and some of that DNA may be degraded during gastrointestinal transit.


Consequently, a standard shotgun metagenomic stool test may fail to identify H. pylori, even when infection is present in the stomach. This is particularly important when a laboratory reports that H. pylori was not detected. Not detected does not necessarily mean not infected.


Currently only histology (gastric biopsy), PCR, stool antigen testing, and urea breath testing are considered valid with known sensitivy and specificity. Unlike established H. pylori diagnostic methods, routine stool shotgun metagenomic testing does not currently have a universally accepted clinical sensitivity for diagnosing this infection. Furthermore, the sensitivity of shotgun metagenomic stool testing for detecting H. pylori in patients taking proton pump inhibitors (PPIs) has not been adequately established. This is particularly important because PPI medications can suppress bacterial density and interfere with the detection of H. pylori by several conventional testing methods. Without reliable studies evaluating shotgun metagenomic testing in patients taking PPIs, we cannot determine how frequently this method may produce false-negative results in this population.



Other Differences From PCR Testing?


Well, first, there is the cost. The particular shotgun metagenomic stool test my patient was considering was less expensive than the PCR-based stool testing we had discussed. The lower cost certainly made this option more attractive, and I suspect it was one of the reasons she was interested in this method. However, a less expensive test is not necessarily a better value if it is less sensitive at detecting the infection we are trying to identify.


When the goal is to identify a specific organism that may be present in very small amounts, a well-designed targeted PCR assay can be more sensitive. PCR selectively amplifies DNA sequences belonging to the organism being investigated. This makes it possible to detect relatively small quantities of that organism's genetic material.

Shotgun sequencing, in comparison, distributes its sequencing effort across the genetic material from many organisms in the specimen. If H. pylori DNA represents only a tiny fraction of the total DNA, the sequencing process may not capture enough of it to identify the infection reliably. This is why I would not automatically consider a negative shotgun metagenomic stool test sufficient to exclude chronic H. pylori infection.



References

  1. Association of Helicobacter pylori Infection with the Gastric Microbiota: A Scoping Review from a Molecular Diagnostic Perspective. Microorganisms. 2026;14(10):2137.https://www.mdpi.com/2076-2607/14/10/2137


Comments


bottom of page